Home Survival StrategiesBags & Loadouts The Single Perfect Survival Knife Myth

The Single Perfect Survival Knife Myth

by Bill Bernhardt

a survival knife with a black handle laying on a log with a stream in the background

Ask most any experienced outdoor survivalist and they will all likely agree that a well designed and properly constructed knife is Man’s best friend when it comes to wrestling subsistence from the wilderness.

However, in so many of the articles published on the topic of how to choose a survival knife, the authors would have you believe that there is such a thing as a single, all-purpose, survival knife that is capable of performing every task that a person needs when attempting to survive in the wilderness.

This is simply not true!

When surviving in the wilderness, a person needs to perform many different tasks such as cutting saplings, splitting logs, constructing traps and snares, and removing the hide from harvested game animals.

Therefore, if a person chooses a large knife optimized for large tasks, then it is ill suited for performing small tasks. The same is true if a person chooses a small knife.

Consequently, rather than carrying a single survival knife and expecting it to do everything you need in a survival situation, a far better solution is to carry more than one.

Instead of thinking of survival knives as single, all-purpose tools, they should instead be thought of as part of a three-part system:

  • a heavy-duty chopping tool
  • a much smaller, fixed-blade, bushcraft knife
  • a folding hunting knife

Chopping Knives

Although they are often overlooked by inexperienced woodsmen, a heavy-duty chopping tool is one of the most user-friendly wilderness survival tools you will ever meet! However, early American bladesmiths were sorely lacking in innovation when it came to heavy-duty chopping tools since Americans imported the hatchet from Europe. The only tool suitable for this purpose that American bladesmiths had developed at the time was the Bowie Knife and, while they are adequate for the job, neither is optimum for the purpose.

Fortunately, because the peoples of Thailand, Malaysia, and the Philippines live in a woody jungle, they have long recognized the need for a large knife designed specifically for chopping wood. They developed such designs as the Parang, the Enep, the Bolo, and the Barong to fill this niche. Also, although the exact shape and length of these knives varies from village to village, each of these designs was specifically developed for cutting hard, woody, vegetation and they all have a characteristic overall shape which makes them easily recognizable to the experienced eye.

Man chopping wood with a knife

While some of these knives are more akin to the South American Machete (which was designed for cutting relatively soft vegetation), in their shorter and heavier versions, they are like a hybrid version of a machete and hatchet. They feature extra-thick spines and extreme weight-forward designs that cut deeply like a hatchet. You get the benefits of a machete while retaining the versatility of a knife.

Tools like the Kershaw Camp 10 (a modern version of the Thai Enep), the Fox Knives Parang XL, or the Bark River Knives Grasso Bolo are all excellent choices for a modern, heavy-duty, chopping tool for wilderness survival.

Kershaw Camp 10

Bushcraft Knives

As a compliment to your heavy-duty chopping tool, you should also add a highly versatile bushcraft knife such as the Randall’s Adventure Training ESSE-5, the KA-BAR Mark 1 or, the Cold Steel Master Hunter to serve as a general purpose tool when the heavy chopping tool is either too big, too heavy or both. Such a knife should have either a Clip Point or a Drop Point blade design, and the blade should measure somewhere between 4 and 5 inches.

Cold Steel Master Hunter

Folding Knives

Because you will find that you have frequent need for your bushcraft knife, you will also find that you need to sharpen it frequently. Thus, it is also helpful to carry a large folding knife such as the Buck model 110 Folding Hunter, the Benchmade Crooked River or, the Ontario Knife Company RAT Model 1. That way, by reserving your folding knife strictly for skinning game animals, you will always have a knife with a razor sharp edge at hand, and you will not have to stop to sharpen your knife prior to processing game.

Buck 110b Folding Hunter – available at BigDaddySurvival.com

Blade Steel

Because you will need to perform many different tasks with your survival knives ranging from chopping, splitting, cutting, and carving to digging in the ground for edible roots and tubers (all of which can be very hard on a knife), you should pay special attention to the steel that the blade is made from.

For instance, blade steels are commonly divided into two categories consisting of high carbon tool steels and stainless steels. As a general rule, high carbon tool steels are significantly tougher than stainless steels although, they do require more care to keep them corrosion free. In addition, due to their composition, high carbon tool steels commonly have a finer grain structure than stainless steels making them more resistant to breaking, and enables them to hold a finer edge.

Diagram of knife steel wear resistance index

via BestPocketKnifeToday.com

But, due to their lack of Chromium and/or Vanadium, high carbon tool steels also lack the carbides that make stainless steels hard. Thus high carbon tool steels need to be sharpened more frequently than stainless steels. You should look for knives with blades made from such steels as 1095, 5160, 65Mn, or A2 but, if you happen to have a distinct preference for stainless steels, it is very difficult to choose a better steel than 440C or AUS-8 for your survival knives.

Final Thoughts

While having any knife at all in a survival situation is far better than having no knife whatsoever, it’s not only unwise but also unnecessary to carry only a single knife and expect it to be able to perform all of the tasks that you will need it to in a survival situation.

Rather than falling victim to the single survival knife myth, a far better option is to think of your survival knives the same way a golfer views his golf clubs. After all, while a person could play eighteen holes of golf with nothing more than a putter or a driver, each golf club is specifically designed to perform a particular task and the same is true of survival knives!

2 comments

Related Articles

2 comments

Arrell Diehl March 13, 2017 - 8:32 pm

I agree with most of this, the basic message is true. Why limit yourself to one or even 2 knives? I do disagree somewhat with the large knife/small knife comparison. A big knife will do everything a small knife will do just maybe not as easily, a small knife cannot do the heavy-duty work a big knife can. If you could only have one knife it should be a big one like the Kershaw Camp 10 shown or a Cold Steel Trailmaster or in the jungle, a machete-type as described. I would take one with saw teeth on the back of the blade-two tools in one! Just not one with a D-guard, makes it almost impossible to use the saw! Instead of a small folder, I would go with a multi-tool like the Leatherman Wave which has TWO knife blades plus all the other tools. As for a medium [4 to 7 inch blade], a lot will depend on the expected use. A hunter, for instance, will have different requirements than a Special Ops warrior. Les Stroud’s Survival Knife is a good multi-purpose knife which could, in an emergency, stand alone. It has a semi-serrated blade, a pommel that will stand up to pounding and comes with a fire steel, whistle, sharpening strip on the back of the sheath and a tip sheet of survival info which stores in the sheath. For general bushcraft use I like the Skandi edge grind. It is fine for all-around use and excels at wood carving. The Tops Knives Brakimo is a fine example of this type. It has TWO divots in the handle [one on each side, why not?] for use as a bearing block for a fire drill and a high-quality Kydex sheath which has a rotating belt clip so it can be worn at any angle, 360 degrees. Anyone care to comment?

Chris March 24, 2017 - 3:58 pm

I rather carry a hatchet you then can use it as a hammer as well

Leave a Comment